FEATURED Places to EAT

Montauk restaurants and shops offer fresh, local seafood throughout the year. Montauk is the biggest commercial port in New York State, and most of our restaurants our restaurants and shops are able to buy locally. So there is not better place to enjoy seafood than Montauk. But if seafood is not your dish, most restaurants offer other menu items. In the summer and fall growing months, many of our restaurants stock up on local produce and fruits.

ARBOR        
arbormontauk.com  
No. 240 Fort Pond Road
631-238-5430
Lunch, Dinner
This Mediterranean restaurant has a casual, chic vibe. Great outside seating, an impressive wine cellar, a 30-foot bar, communal table, and a sunken dining room with traditional seating. The farm-to-table menu of executive chef Pierre Sudre has small and large plates with fresh seafood, duck, and steak. Cheeseburgers and tuna sliders are lunch choices. Raw oysters, clams, and chilled lobster are on the menu and a selection of home made pizzas. Arbor has 16 wines by the glass at the appropriate temperature, along with 12 beers on tap and over 50 wines by the bottle.

DURYEA’S LOBSTER DECK
duryealobsters.com
65 Tuthill Road
631-668-2410
Lunch, Dinner
The view from the tables over Fort Pond Bay and Gardiner’s Island is superb. Great outdoor Duryea vibe with a classic menu including grilled or steamed lobster, fresh local fish, and Duryea’s famous lobster roll, also a Clam Bake, small plates, salads, raw platters, and a kids menu.

EAST BY NORTHEAST
eastbynortheast.com
51 Edgemere Road

631-668-2872
Overlooking Montauk’s Fort Pond, East By Northeast serves Zagat rated cuisine, influenced by both the Far East and the Northeast. The menu features fresh Montauk seafood and shellfish, and the best of the East End farms locally grown produce with Long Island and New World wines. Featuring a sushi/raw bar. Enjoy live music weekends at the Bar and Lounge. Perfect for hosting weddings and other special events for up to 200 guests. Open for dinner at 5:00 year round.

GOSMAN’S TOPSIDE AND INLET CAFÉ   
gosmans.com
484 Westlake Drive
631-668-2549
Lunch, Dinner
Great views, seafood, and outside seating right on the water. The Inlet serves daily specials and also prepares sushi with the fish brought right into their dock. A picturesque outdoor bar has an extensive cocktail menu that specializes in frozen refreshments.

HARVEST ON FORT POND
harvestfortpond.com
11 South Emery Street

631-668-5574
Dinner
Great outside setting. One of Montauk’s top restaurants, the Harvest On Fort Pond has a well-deserved reputation as friendly and sophisticated. Situated on Fort Pond, the Harvest also has a lovely herb and vegetable garden in which to dine alfresco. Jake Williams, the chef, prepares Tuscan fare served in family-style portions, emphasizing local seafood and home-grown produce. The Harvest has a sophisticated bar and lounge serving creative cocktails and a view of the sunset over the pond. A great spot to host a wedding or other special event for up to 90 people. Dinner from 5 pm daily.

INLET SEAFOOD RESTAURANT
inletseafood.com      

541 East Lake Drive
631-668-4272
Lunch, Dinner, Sunday Brunch
A beautiful waterfront restaurant with spectacular sunset views overlooking the sound, right at the end of East Lake Drive. Named one of the 10 best seafood restaurants on Long Island by Newsday in 2015, the Inlet is owned by six commercial fishermen from Montauk. Watch the boats cruise in and out of the Harbor while enjoying super fresh seafood, sushi and lobster caught daily from local fishing boats. Or watch the scene from the bar with one of their signature cocktails. Steaks, burgers, and pasta are also on the menu. Inside and deck dining available.

SAMMY’S    
sammysmtk.com      
448 West Lake Drive
631-238-5707
Lunch, Dinner
Chef Sam Joyce’s dockside restaurant is casual, family-friendly, and very Montauk. Local flavor lives in the famous Lobster Burger, Mary’s Lobster Roll and Shrimp Po Boy, plus clams and oysters on the half shell, grilled steak, or soft tacos. Entrées available in smaller portions. Soups, salads, and sandwiches also available. Sit inside or on the patio and watch boats in the Harbor. Look for Sammy’s food truck at the harbor entrance. Available for private parties. Open 7 days, in the season.

THE BACKYARD RESTAURANT AT SOLE EAST  
soleeast.com
90 Second House Road
631-668-9737
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
Entertainment Beautiful courtyard setting. Fresh, locally sourced Mediterranean-influenced menu features fresh catch from local fishermen and organic meats and vegetables. Dine in or outside in the gardens, or lounge poolside and enjoy a cocktail as you listen to the DJ spin.

THE POINT BAR AND GRILL
pointbarandgrill.com
697 Montauk Highway

631-668-1500
Lunch, Dinner, After Dark
This iconic watering hole and eatery with big-screen TV, sports features casual fare including wraps, burgers, mussels, and buffalo wings along with signature dishes, such as a 16-ounce steak and fresh Montauk seafood. Half price appetizers and drinks during happy hour Mon. through Fri. See all MLB games and in the fall enjoy NFL Sunday Ticket. Open daily and late.

WESTLAKE FISH HOUSE  
westlakefishhouse.com       
352 Westlake Drive
631-668-FISH (3474)
Breakfast, Lunch, & Dinner
Located at the Westlake Marina, right next to the docks, this restaurant has that old Montauk vibe combined with new and innovative ways to serve seafood from renowned chef Larry Kolar. Sit inside or outside at the Dockside Bar and watch boats come in with their catch. Opens at 5 am with brunch every day. Lobster benedict or an energy burrito, anyone? Dinner items include shrimp enchilada, grilled salmon, and St. Louis ribs plus fresh sushi and a raw bar, even a kid’s menu. Families welcomed. Live music weekly. 5am-10pm daily, in the season.

Click here for complete listing

GOSMAN’S TOPSIDE AND INLET CAFÉ   
gosmans.com
484 Westlake Drive
631-668-2549
Lunch, Dinner
Great views, seafood, and outside seating right on the water. The Inlet serves daily specials and also prepares sushi with the fish brought right into their dock. A picturesque outdoor bar has an extensive cocktail menu that specializes in frozen refreshments.

GRINGOS BURRITO GRILL
gringosburritogrillmtk.com
805 Montauk Highway
631-668-7500
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
Head to the east end of the village to get fresh, bespoke burritos, tacos, bowls and more, using house made salsa and guacamole. Featuring cilantro-lime chicken, marinated steak, fish, and build-your-own nachos. Breakfast burritos are a must. Beer, wine, and sangria can be enjoyed on the patio.

HOODOOS  
hoodoosmtk.com        
38 South Etna Avenue
631-238-5791
Lunch
Located two blocks from the beach and in town, Hoodoos serves great brunch and sandwiches. Dine in the garden or take your lunch to the beach. Specializing in local and organic eggs, meat, and fish. Hoodoos is part of the Naturally Good team.

JOHN’S DRIVE-IN                 
677 Montauk Highway
631-668-5515
Lunch, Dinner
GO HERE NOW! Continue reading this guide over ice cream and a fishwich! A Montauk institution serving genuinely awesome burgers, fries, and all the best diner items you can think of (like the fishwich), plus the BEST HOMEMADE ICE CREAM ON LONG ISLAND, with 20+flavors. The lines don’t lie… and yes, it’s worth the wait. Hit Harvest for dinner in their bucolic garden on the pond then walk over to John’s for a nightcap of succulent Cherry Vanilla ice cream…you’ll call the real estate broker on the way home.11:30am–10pm.

NATURALLY GOOD CAFÉ
naturallygoodcafe.com        
779 Montauk Highway
631-668-9030
Breakfast, Lunch, Natural Food Groceries Healthy mainstay. A very popular year-round restaurant in the village serving healthy organic food. Breakfast features organic breakfast tortillas, oatmeal, pancakes and more. Homemade bread accompanies the soups at lunch, and the tuna sandwiches are made with the real thing. Specials made daily include homemade soups and veggie burgers, veggie stir-frys, burritos, salads, and wraps. Organic groceries also featured.

NAVY BEACH
navybeach.com        
16 Navy Road
631-668-6868
Lunch, Dinner
This laid-back, family-friendly beachfront restaurant and bar is on a beautiful stretch of beach on Fort Pond Bay. Enjoy casual coastal cuisine with an emphasis on sustainable seafood and local seasonal produce. Signature dishes include Local Catch Ceviche, Buttermilk Fried Chicken, and the Lobster & Clam Bake. Dine inside or at picnic tables outside on the beach and watch breathtaking sunsets over the water and the boats that moor offshore. A perfect place for weddings or other events. Open seven days in the season.

PIZZA VILLAGE      
pizzavillagemontauk.com    
700 Montauk Highway
631-668-2232
Lunch, Dinner
Pizza Village has been serving pizzas and other Italian dishes in the village since 1957. Using the freshest ingredients everything is homemade daily. Offering three sizes of pies and a menu full of Italian family fare such as baked ziti, veal parmigiana, spaghetti and meatballs, and linguine with clam sauce. A friendly place where families are welcomed. Delivery and catering available. Open daily from 11:30 am.

PRIMAVERA PIZZA            
54 South Erie Avenue
631-668-1601
Lunch, Dinner
Across from the baseball field, Primavera is the best choice in Montauk for homemade Italian specialties and pizzas made in brick-lined ovens. The grandma pie is heaven for pizza lovers. Specialties like focaccia sandwiches, salads, soups, pasta dinners, pizza and even tiramisu are made from scratch. Open seven days, in the season. Take-out only but tables are provided on the grass outside, great for a casual family lunch or dinner. Event catering.

SAMMYS     
sammysmtk.com      
448 West Lake Drive
631-238-5707
Lunch, Dinner
Chef Sam Joyce’s dockside restaurant is casual, family-friendly, and very Montauk. Local flavor lives in the famous Lobster Burger, Mary’s Lobster Roll and Shrimp Po Boy, plus clams and oysters on the half shell, grilled steak, or soft tacos. Entrées available in smaller portions. Soups, salads, and sandwiches also available. Sit inside or on the patio and watch boats in the Harbor. Look for Sammy’s food truck at the harbor entrance. Available for private parties. Open 7 days, in the season.

THE BACKYARD RESTAURANT AT SOLE EAST  
soleeast.com
No. 90 Second House Road
631-668-9737
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner,
Entertainment Beautiful courtyard setting. Fresh, locally sourced Mediterranean-influenced menu features fresh catch from local fishermen and organic meats and vegetables. Dine in or outside in the gardens, or lounge poolside and enjoy a cocktail as you listen to the DJ spin.

THE POINT BAR AND GRILL
pointbarandgrill.com
697 Montauk Highway

631-668-1500
Lunch, Dinner, After Dark
This iconic watering hole and eatery with big-screen TV, sports features casual fare including wraps, burgers, mussels, and buffalo wings along with signature dishes, such as a 16-ounce steak and fresh Montauk seafood. Half price appetizers and drinks during happy hour Mon. through Fri. See all MLB games and in the fall enjoy NFL Sunday Ticket. Open daily and late.

WESTLAKE FISH HOUSE  
westlakefishhouse.com       
352 Westlake Drive
631-668-FISH (3474)
Breakfast, Lunch, & Dinner
Located at the Westlake Marina, right next to the docks, this restaurant has that old Montauk vibe combined with new and innovative ways to serve seafood from renowned chef Larry Kolar. Sit inside or outside at the Dockside Bar and watch boats come in with their catch. Opens at 5 am with brunch every day. Lobster benedict or an energy burrito, anyone? Dinner items include shrimp enchilada, grilled salmon, and St. Louis ribs plus fresh sushi and a raw bar, even a kid’s menu. Families welcomed. Live music weekly. 5am-10pm daily, in the season.

Click here for complete listing

DURYEA’S LOBSTER DECK
duryealobsters.com

65 Tuthill Road
631-668-2410
Lunch, Dinner
The view from the tables over Fort Pond Bay and Gardiner’s Island is superb. Great outdoor Duryea vibe with a classic menu including grilled or steamed lobster, fresh local fish, and Duryea’s famous lobster roll, also a Clam Bake, small plates, salads, raw platters, and a kids menu.

GOSMAN’S TOPSIDE AND INLET CAFÉ   
gosmans.com
484 Westlake Drive
631-668-2549
Lunch, Dinner
Great views, seafood, and outside seating right on the water. The Inlet serves daily specials and also prepares sushi with the fish brought right into their dock. A picturesque outdoor bar has an extensive cocktail menu that specializes in frozen refreshments.

HARVEST ON FORT POND
harvestfortpond.com
11 South Emery Street

631-668-5574
Dinner
Great outside setting. One of Montauk’s top restaurants, the Harvest On Fort Pond has a well-deserved reputation as friendly and sophisticated. Situated on Fort Pond, the Harvest also has a lovely herb and vegetable garden in which to dine alfresco. Jake Williams, the chef, prepares Tuscan fare served in family-style portions, emphasizing local seafood and home-grown produce. The Harvest has a sophisticated bar and lounge serving creative cocktails and a view of the sunset over the pond. A great spot to host a wedding or other special event for up to 90 people. Dinner from 5 pm daily.

INLET SEAFOOD RESTAURANT   
inletseafood.com      
541 East Lake Drive
631-668-4272
Lunch, Dinner, Sunday Brunch
A beautiful waterfront restaurant with spectacular sunset views overlooking the sound, right at the end of East Lake Drive. Named one of the 10 best seafood restaurants on Long Island by Newsday in 2015, the Inlet is owned by six commercial fishermen from Montauk. Watch the boats cruise in and out of the Harbor while enjoying super fresh seafood, sushi and lobster caught daily from local fishing boats. Or watch the scene from the bar with one of their signature cocktails. Steaks, burgers, and pasta are also on the menu. Inside and deck dining available.

JOHN’S DRIVE-IN                  
677 Montauk Hwy
631-668-5515
Lunch, Dinner
GO HERE NOW! Continue reading this guide over ice cream and a fishwich! A Montauk institution serving genuinely awesome burgers, fries, and all the best diner items you can think of (like the fishwich), plus the BEST HOMEMADE ICE CREAM ON LONG ISLAND, with 20+flavors. The lines don’t lie… and yes, it’s worth the wait. Hit Harvest for dinner in their bucolic garden on the pond then walk over to John’s for a nightcap of succulent Cherry Vanilla ice cream…you’ll call the real estate broker on the way home.11:30am–10pm.

NAVY BEACH
navybeach.com        
16 Navy Road
631-668-6868
Lunch, Dinner
This laid-back, family-friendly beachfront restaurant and bar is on a beautiful stretch of beach on Fort Pond Bay. Enjoy casual coastal cuisine with an emphasis on sustainable seafood and local seasonal produce. Signature dishes include Local Catch Ceviche, Buttermilk Fried Chicken, and the Lobster & Clam Bake. Dine inside or at picnic tables outside on the beach and watch breathtaking sunsets over the water and the boats that moor offshore. A perfect place for weddings or other events. Open seven days in season.

THE CLAM BAR
clambarhamptons.com       
2025 Montauk Highway, Amagansett
631-267-6348
Serving Noon ’til dark.
An outdoor restaurant stalwart on the Napeague Stretch (north side) west of the village with the freshest seafood and a Montauk vibe. Sit under an umbrella and soak in the atmosphere, listen to golden oldies, enjoy a bowl of clam chowder or dig into fresh local lobster. There is no better place to eat fresh local steamers or clams. A great selection of fresh fish and raw clams. Open April to November.

Click here for complete listing

MONTAUK MARKET         
805 Montauk Highway
631-668-2071
BAKERY! BAKERY! Montauk Market, east end of town next to Martell’s, is a superb bakery and market serving freshly made muffins, croissants, bread, bagels, flagels, cookies, bialys, pies and more. MM starts at 5 am serving full breakfast, including egg white wraps, burritos, omelets, French toast, pancakes, fresh fruit salads, yogurt & granola, and natural veggie juices and smoothies. The lunch menu includes thirty different sandwich combos and home-made salads. Serving hot and cold platters for dinner with Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. They’ll make you a basket for the beach. Catering and bespoke specialty cakes and pies.    

Click here for complete listing

ANTHONY’S PANCAKE AND WAFFLE HOUSE
710 Main Street
631-668-9705
A Montauk classic serving breakfast and lunch right in the village since 1952. Breakfast favorites include French toast, omelets, eggs Benedict, waffles, crepes, fruit-filled pancakes and other specialty pancakes, along with bagels and lox. Lunch specialties offer salads and gyros along with sandwiches, burgers and more.  Ice-cream sodas, floats, and sundaes are also on the menu. Families welcome, takeout available. Open daily 7am-2pm.

BIRD ON THE ROOF          
47 South Elmwood Avenue
631-668-5833
Breakfast, Lunch
Breakfast favorite. The seagull painted on the roof of this downtown classic A-frame points the way to one of Montauk’s favorite breakfast spots. Enjoy eggs Benedict with smoked salmon or prosciutto, omelets, frittatas, or pancakes, and then browse through Bird’s beach boutique for clothes and accessories. Dine indoors or on the patio or back garden from 8am-1:30pm, 7 days.

M & R Delicatessen           
728 Montauk Highway
631-668-8600
Breakfast , Lunch, Dinner
Montauk’s best deli! Located in the heart of town serving all the classics that will keep you coming back for more! Build your own salad bar, Specialty sandwiches, panini, egg sandwiches. Open year round.

MONTAUK MARKET         
805 Montauk Highway
631-668-2071
BAKERY! BAKERY! Montauk Market, east end of town next to Martell’s, is a superb bakery and market serving freshly made muffins, croissants, bread, bagels, flagels, cookies, bialys, pies and more. MM starts at 5 am serving full breakfast, including egg white wraps, burritos, omelets, French toast, pancakes, fresh fruit salads, yogurt & granola, and natural veggie juices and smoothies. The lunch menu includes thirty different sandwich combos and home-made salads. Serving hot and cold platters for dinner with Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. They’ll make you a basket for the beach. Catering and bespoke specialty cakes and pies.               

Click here for complete listing

MARSHALL’S
marshallandsons.com
701 Montauk Highway

631-668-2990
This Main Street service station has a handy convenience store, open for coffee and snacks, summer drinks, plus cool, imported beers, and fine humidor cigars. 5:30 am -11 pm, 7 days, in season.

MONTAUK MARKET
805 Montauk Highway
631-668-2071
BAKERY! BAKERY! Montauk Market, east end of town next to Martell’s, is a superb bakery and market serving freshly made muffins, croissants, bread, bagels, flagels, cookies, bialys, pies and more. MM starts at 5 am serving full breakfast, including egg white wraps, burritos, omelets, French toast, pancakes, fresh fruit salads, yogurt & granola, and natural veggie juices and smoothies. The lunch menu includes thirty different sandwich combos and home-made salads. Serving hot and cold platters for dinner with Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. They’ll make you a basket for the beach. Catering and bespoke specialty cakes and pies.

Click here for complete listing

BEN & JERRY’S      
benjerry.com/montauk
West Lake Drive Extension at the Harbor 631-668-9425
Ice Cream, Desserts, Coffee Bar
An institution in Montauk serving Vermont’s Finest, GMO free and fair trade ice cream, frozen yogurt, fresh fruit sorbets, soft serve and non-dairy dessert. Visit the adjoining Espresso bar featuring locally roasted Fair Trade Organic coffee and an assortment of teas, treats, gift items, and the East End’s largest variety of B&J’s “pints to go!”

FUDGE N STUFF    
41 S Edgemere Street
631-668-4724
On the Circle, just off  Main Street, Fudge N’ Stuff is jam-packed with goodies, including 30 different kinds of fudge, and, yes, they’ll slice you a taste so you can sample until you find your favorite. An eye-pop-ping assortment of old-fashioned penny candy, lollipops, gourmet jellybeans, cotton candy, hot popcorn, nuts, and chocolate-covered pretzels by the pound fi ll the shelves. Wonderful soft serve ice cream as well. Order an ice-cream cone, sundae, malt, or banana split, or a hot chocolate or cappuccino. They also sell piñatas for your parties. Cravings satisfied from 10am-11pm, 7 days in season.

MONTAUK MARKET  
805 Montauk Highway
631-668-2071
BAKERY! BAKERY! Montauk Market, east end of town next to Martell’s, is a superb bakery and market serving freshly made muffins, croissants, bread, bagels, flagels, cookies, bialys, pies and more. MM starts at 5 am serving full breakfast, including egg white wraps, burritos, omelets, French toast, pancakes, fresh fruit salads, yogurt & granola, and natural veggie juices and smoothies. The lunch menu includes thirty different sandwich combos and home-made salads. Serving hot and cold platters for dinner with Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. They’ll make you a basket for the beach. Catering and bespoke specialty cakes and pies.

Click here for complete listing
ON MONTAUK