653 Montauk Highway
ALIMENTARY BEACH MONTAUK
752 Montauk Hwy
Gourmet Italian foods and goods.
BALSAM FARMS MONTAUK MARKET
662 Montauk Hwy Unit 1
Our commitment to good food also means a commitment to safe food, and that includes the ways we plant, grow, harvest, wash, pack, and deliver our produce to you. During harvest it means washing hands, harvest tools, and harvest bins, and maintaining clean washing and packing areas. After harvest we immediately clean, hydrate, and cool crops with fresh water, pack them in clean bins, and quickly store them at proper temperatures in our coolers to ensure that we provide our customers and CSA members with the freshest and safest produce possible. Our commitment also extends to all our jarred goods and prepared foods, which are always made fresh in certified kitchens by skilled chefs trained in the most current food safety standards. Each year, we also donate a portion of our produce to local charity organizations to help feed those in need in our community – and our practices apply there as well.
GOSMAN’S FISH MARKET
484 West Lake Drive
Locally caught fish direct from Gosman’s own docks, live or cooked lobsters from their tanks, shrimp, clams, fresh local produce, baked goods, gourmet items, make this a popular place to browse and buy all you need for lunch or dinner. Open daily 10:00 am – 6:00 pm in season. Call for off-season hours.
HERB’S MONTAUK MARKET
778 Montauk Highway
654 Montauk Hwy
701 Montauk Highway
This Main Street service station has a handy convenience store with coffee and snacks, summer drinks, plus cool, imported beers and fine humidor cigars. Pop in while strolling or after filling up.
MONTAUK BEER & SODAS
43 S Elmwood Avenue
805 Montauk Highway
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, BAKERY! Many new vegetarian options. Montauk Market is a superb bakery and market opening at 5am serving fresh muffins, croissants, breads, bagels, flagels, cookies, bialys, pies, or full breakfasts like egg white wraps, omelets, fresh fruit salads, yogurt & granola, plus veggie juices and smoothies. Lunch includes sandwich combos and homemade salads; dinnertime features hot and cold platters, Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. They cater and can make you a to-go beach basket.
NEW! TONY’S MEAT MARKET MONTAUK
541 West Lake Drive
Located in the heart of Montauk Harbor across from the Viking Fleet, at what was once “Gaviola’s Market” and then “The Market”, Tony’s Meat Market is committed to keeping the old-world traditions of butchery alive serving its local community. Come by for prime cut quality meats, flavor-packed specialty sausages, burgers, hot foods, specialty sandwiches, along with fresh coffee, beer, artisanal breads, groceries, and more. Stop in as early as 5am for coffee and breakfast before a day of fishing or at lunch for classic sandwiches and salads from our gourmet delicatessen for your day at the beach. At the heart of our store, our butchers will provide the highest quality meat and cooked foods, perfect for your backyard barbeque or casual Monday night dinner table. We’ve been serving the South Shore of Long Island for 32 years and are excited to be a part of the Montauk neighborhood!
Click the links below for complete listings: