Beverages and Cafés

BLUESTONE LANE

bluestonelaneny.com
No. 786 Montauk Highway
631-483-5078
Montauk meets Australia at this newly opened coffee shop in the village, which also has an outpost at the Surf Lodge. Serving Aussie Style coffee, including their famous “Flat White”” and other hot and cold coffee and non-coffee drinks, along with pastries, (some gluten free) and an Aussie cake called Lamingtons. The decor, light and bright with natural woods has the look of an Aussi Surf town, which is very similar if not the same as our Montauk surf town look. Also serving Van Leeuwen artisan ice cream, some vegan flavors. Opens at 7:30 am. Closes Mon-Thurs at 4 pm, Fri-Sun at 10 pm.

BREAKERS MTK

breakersmtk.com
769 Old Montauk Hwy
(631) 668-2525
NEW! Breakfast, Lunch
Location Location Location. Breakers MTK is a new, laid back, ocean-view eatery nestled into Breakers Motel along a beautiful stretch of Old Montauk Highway close to town, offering casual dining indoors and al fresco, poolside service, full bar, elevated grab & go offerings, and a signature take-out menu with online ordering. Weekend brunch beckons, as do wine, beer, and creative cocktails après beach.

NEW! HAMPTON COFFEE COMPANY

hamptoncoffeecompany.com
732 Montauk Highway
631-668-8206
A Hamptons classic since 1994 opens its first store in Montauk in 2020. Super-premium estate-grown specialty coffees roasted daily by hand in small batches, plus a wide array of goodies to compliment your beverages. Enjoy the large outdoor patio or take it to go. HCC is a family run, community-focused business that provides quality jobs with benefits to locals year round.

LEFT HAND COFFEE

lefthandcoffee.com  
83 S Elmwood Avenue     
631-238-5434

M&R DELI

728 Montauk Highway
631-668-8600
Breakfast, Lunch
Montauk’s best deli, in a killer location! Montauker Matt Meehan (owner of Gringo’s as well) always wanted a deli and, well, he’s doing this right, you’ll see. Located in the heart of town serving Montauk twists on classic deli fare, including great breakfast sandwiches, pastries and coffee. But that’s not all, Matt’s fried chicken is to die for, no kidding. Call ahead and ask if they have it. Also build your own salad bar, specialty sandwiches, panini, and egg sandwiches. Open year round.

MONTAUK JUICE FACTORY

montaukjuicefactory.com   
12 S Etna Avenue
631-668-8286

MONTAUK BAKE SHOPPE

montaukbakeshoppe.com
29 The Plaza A
631-668-2439
Breakfast, Lunch
A Montauk institution is the Bake Shoppe. Fresh everything in the morning displayed for easy viewing in classic bakery style. Classic bakery items mingle with specialties like rugelach, quiche, and exotic cookie creations. Homemade doughnuts, cakes and…wow, those breakfast wraps are so big and juicy you could skip lunch. Coffee, juices, refreshments also. Takeout or grab a table outside and people watch.

MONTAUK MARKET         

805 Montauk Highway     
631-668-2071
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, BAKERY! Many new vegetarian options in 2020. Montauk Market is a superb bakery and market opening at 5am serving fresh muffins, croissants, breads, bagels, flagels, cookies, bialys, pies, or full breakfasts like egg white wraps, omelets, fresh fruit salads, yogurt & granola, plus veggie juices and smoothies. Lunch includes sandwich combos and homemade salads; dinnertime features hot and cold platters, Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. They cater and can make you a to-go beach basket.

WHITES LIQUOR AND WINE

771 Montauk Highway
631-668-2426
Whites is chocked full of wines and other spirits, including Sake, and is a Montauk classic. They’ll deliver free and have great staff that know the massive inventory well.

Click the links below for complete listings: