Fort Pond, a large freshwater lake, spans a distance from the village north to Fort Pond Bay, which is a large bay on the Long Island Sound side of Montauk. Several hotels and restaurants rim the lake and also the bay, and the Montauk Manor sits on a high hill overlooking it all.
Featured Places to Stay
MONTAUK MANOR RESORT
236 Edgemere Street, Montauk, NY 11954
631-668-4400
Open all year
(On 12 acres overlooking Gardiner’s Bay & Block Island Sound)
140 units with indoor and outdoor pools, tennis, kitchens, A/C, and a restaurant, Tre Bella, on premises.
Read Jennifer S.'s review of Montauk Manor on Yelp
THE STONE LION INN
51 Edgemere Street Montauk, NY 11954
631-668-2872
Open All Year
11 units, one is a duplex, all with balconies overlooking Fort Pond, A/C, TV with HBO and coffeepots. Quick walk to the Village. Newly decorated rooms. Restaurant on premises. No children or pets.
Read Sourivone V.'s review of Stone Lion Inn on Yelp
MONTAUKET HOTEL
88 Firestone Road Montauk, NY 11954
631-267-5992
Open late March – November
Located on the Block Island Sound, overlooking Gardiner’s Island and Fort Pond Bay
18 units with kitchenettes, restaurant
Read Matthew M.'s review of Montauket Hotel on Yelp