HAMPTON COFFEE COMPANY
732 Montauk Highway
631-668-8206
A Hamptons classic since 1994 opens its first store in Montauk in 2020. Super-premium estate-grown specialty coffees roasted daily by hand in small batches, plus a wide array of goodies to compliment your beverages. Enjoy the large outdoor patio or take it to go. HCC is a family run, community-focused business that provides quality jobs with benefits to locals year round.
MONTAUK BAKE SHOPPE
montaukbakeshoppe.com
No. 29 The Plaza
631-668-2439
A Montauk institution is the Bake Shoppe. Fresh everything in the morning displayed for easy viewing in classic bakery style. Classic bakery items mingle with specialties like rugelach, quiche, and exotic cookie creations. Homemade doughnuts, cakes and…wow, those breakfast wraps are so big and juicy you could skip lunch. Coffee, juices, refreshments also. Takeout or grab a table outside and people watch.
MONTAUK MARKET
montaukmarketeast.com
805 Montauk Highway
631-668-2071
BAKERY! BAKERY! Montauk Market is a superb bakery and market opening at 5am serving fresh muffins, croissants, breads, bagels, flagels, cookies, bialys, pies, or full breakfasts like egg white wraps, omelets, fresh fruit salads, yogurt & granola, plus veggie juices and smoothies. Lunch includes endless sandwich combos and homemade salads while dinnertime features hot and cold platters, Italian specialties and Latin-American dishes. They cater and can make you a to-go basket for the beach!
CANDIED ANCHOR
721 Montauk Highway
631-668-8038
Located in the heart of Montauk, The Candied Anchor is a 1950’s sweet shop with a modern sensibility. Equal parts classic Americana and organic Bohemia, The Anchor is sure to delight even the most stubborn sweet tooth. In it, you’ll find party supplies, baked confections, ice cream, quirky retro gifts, and, of course, all the candy you could possibly want.
FUDGE-N-STUFF
41 S Edgemere Street
631-668-4724
Seen Willy Wonka? Fudge N’Stuff is jam-packed with goodies, including 30 different kinds of fudge, an eye-popping assortment of old-fashioned penny candy, lollipops, gourmet jellybeans, cotton candy, hot popcorn, nuts, and chocolate-covered pretzels. Craving soft serve ice cream, sundaes, malts, banana splits, hot chocolate or a cappuccino? No problem. Oh, piñatas too. 10am-11pm in season.
JOHN’S DRIVE IN
677 Montauk Hwy
631-668-5515
Lunch, Dinner
GO HERE NOW! Continue reading this guide over ice cream and a fishwich! A Montauk institution serving genuinely awesome burgers, fries, and all the best diner items you can think of (like the fishwich), plus the BEST HOMEMADE ICE CREAM ON LONG ISLAND, with 20+flavors. The lines don’t lie… and yes, it’s worth the wait. Hit Harvest for dinner in their bucolic garden on the pond then walk over to John’s for a nightcap of succulent Cherry Vanilla ice cream…you’ll call the real estate broker on the way home. 11:30am–10pm.
Click the links below for complete listings: